Numerical
Methods in System Simulations
The numerical methods used in the
discussed system simulations are not basically new, but the generally available
ones are adequately selected and adapted to the specific wide range of
system applications. The simulation problem discussed here is a tridimensional
one from the beginning. The antennas, the ground and the objects have to
be treated and modeled adequately. The objects range from large cubical
metallic buildings or aircraft with curved surfaces to wire and skeleton
type masts or tower-cranes which may interact with each other or with the
exciting systems antenna. The most important condition to be met is that
all the methods has to be strictly applied only within their range of definitions
and their applicability. Otherwise the results are questionable and speculations
– in principle worthless.
The preferred methods are the asymptotic
ones, e.g. the Geometrical Theory of Diffraction GTD and its derivatives
the UTD etc. The first system simulation method developed was the tridimensional
GTD/UTD-method applied for the ILS-system /1/, later for VOR/DVOR and other
systems. The GTD/UTD-method was the preferred one compared with the PO-method
and derivatives due to the wider range of general applicability. For single
objects the Physical Optics Method PO with its improvements IPO (rim currents
and shadow Fock-currents). However, limitations in the GTD/UTD-method and
an increasing demand to treat objects not reasonably possible with PO nor
with GTD/UTD has led to the introduction of the moment method technique
MoM in the applied system simulations. This is for wire type cranes on
airports, for electrically medium size objects or for the bistatic scattering
of a complete aircraft.
A further recently expanded numerical
method has been introduced now and integrated into the entire system simulation,
namely the parabolic equation method which can handle in the forward propagation
mode complicated ground and material structures. Extentions for the 3D
case and the backward propagation are under way. A multilayer ground (e.g.
dry and wet snow) is treated in this approach by an approximate reflection-refraction
transmission line method.
All these methods are combined in
an applied novel modular hybrid system simulation approach:
-
3D GTD/UTD as the basic method for the
3D scattering of multi-scatterers and ground (Fig. 2)
-
PO and IPO method for curved surface
objects (aircraft) (Fig. 4)
-
Moment method for the antennas and adequate
objects (cranes, masts, wind generators etc.) (Fig. 3)
-
parabolic equation PE for the wave propagation
on irregular and complicated 3D ground (Fig. 2)
-
reflection-refraction transmission line
method for multilayer problems
This 3D system treatment, the modular
integration of the different methods into a system simulation has opened
the reliable numerical treatment for a class of problems and for systems
present on actual modern airports and en-route.
The methods are applicable in principle
for landing systems and navigational as well as for radar systems. However,
the frequency for the radar systems of interest (ASR,SSR) is generally
higher. Primarily the asymptotic GTD/UTD method is the preferred one. Details
may be analyzed by the PO/IPO whereas the MoM is in the most cases not
applicable due to the required computer storage and/or the computer processing
time.